/

Business tips

/

Pros and Cons of Leasing vs. Buying a New Car: How to Decide to Lease or Buy a Car and its Business Tax Implications

10 minute read

Lease or Buy a New Car for Your Business: Is it Better to Lease or Buy a Car?

By

on

Deciding whether to lease or buy a new car can be overwhelming. This comprehensive guide delves deep into the pros and cons of each option, helping you make an informed decision. Whether looking for flexibility, long-term value, or something in between, this article covers all bases.

Introduction to Buying and Leasing a Car: Basics for Businesses

Understanding the Fundamentals

Leasing a new car or buying a new car are two distinct paths for a business when acquiring a vehicle. Each option affects the company's financial health differently, especially regarding monthly payments, tax implications, and asset management. Leasing a new car typically involves lower monthly payments than buying a new one. This can be beneficial for businesses that want to conserve their cash flow and can upgrade their vehicles regularly. However, it's important to consider the restrictions on mileage and potential wear and tear charges that come with a lease.

On the other hand, buying a new car may result in higher monthly payments, but the business ultimately owns the asset. This can be advantageous for businesses that plan to keep the vehicle for an extended period of time and want to avoid mileage restrictions. Additionally, owning the vehicle may have tax advantages such as depreciation deductions.

Regarding tax implications, leasing a new car may allow businesses to deduct the entire lease payment as a business expense. However, buying a new car may provide opportunities for tax benefits such as depreciation and interest deductions.

Regarding asset management, leasing a new car may not appear as a liability on the business's balance sheet, which can improve the company's financial ratios. However, buying a new car results in the business owning the asset, which can be beneficial in terms of long-term value and potential resale or trade-in value.

Ultimately, whether a business chooses to lease or buy a new car will depend on its specific financial situation, long-term vehicle needs, and tax considerations. It's important for businesses to carefully evaluate the costs and benefits of each option before making a decision. 

Leasing a Vehicle: A Flexible Approach

Leasing a car involves a contract where a business pays for using the car over a specified lease term, typically two to four years. At the end of the lease, the business must return the car to the dealer or choose to buy it. Leasing a car requires a business to enter into a contractual agreement to pay for the temporary use of the vehicle for a set period, usually two to four years. Upon the lease's completion, the business must either return the car to the dealer or may opt to purchase it. 

Buying a Vehicle: Long-term Investment

Buying a car means the business owns the vehicle outright by paying cash or a car loan. This approach can be more cost-effective over time, as the business can build equity in the car. Purchasing a car entails the company owning the vehicle by making a cash payment or taking out a car loan. This method can be more economical in the long run, as the company can establish an ownership stake in the car. 

Business Tax Implications: Leasing a Car

Immediate Tax Deductions

When a business opts to lease a car, it can often claim the lease payments as a deductible business expense. This can significantly lower the taxable income of the business. However, there are IRS limits on how much can be deducted, which are influenced by factors such as the type of car and its usage. Generally, the IRS allows businesses to deduct the business use portion of their lease payments for a car. However, if the car is also used for personal use, the portion of the lease payments attributable to personal use cannot be deducted.

Additionally, there are limits on the amount that can be deducted based on the type of car. The IRS sets a maximum depreciation limit for cars each year, influenced by the type of car and the year it was placed in service.

Businesses need to keep detailed records of their car usage and lease payments to calculate their deductible expenses accurately. Failure to do so may result in the IRS disallowing the deduction, leading to additional tax liabilities and potential penalties.
As always, working with a qualified tax professional is recommended to ensure compliance with IRS regulations and maximize the tax benefits of leasing a car for business use. 

Business Tax Implications: Buying a Car

Capitalizing and Depreciating the Asset

Purchasing a new car allows a business to capitalize and depreciate the vehicle over its life. This depreciation is a tax-deductible business expense. The specific tax benefits vary based on the type of car, with certain vehicles offering larger depreciation benefits. In addition to the tax benefits, purchasing a new car for business use can also provide the business with a reliable and efficient mode of transportation. This can help improve the company's operations, as it allows employees to travel to meetings, make deliveries, or visit clients without worrying about the reliability of their vehicles.

Furthermore, a new car may also come with the latest safety and technology features, which can help improve overall safety for employees and reduce the risk of accidents or breakdowns. This can also help lower insurance costs for the business.

Lastly, purchasing a new car may also positively affect the company's image. A sleek and modern vehicle can reflect positively on the business and help make a good impression on clients and customers.

Overall, purchasing a new car for business use can have various financial and operational benefits for a company. It's important to carefully consider the specific needs and circumstances of the business before making a decision, but in many cases, it can be a sound investment. 

Comparing Lease and Loan Payments: Tax Perspectives

Lease Payments vs. Car Loan Payments

Lease payments are often lower than car loan payments for a similar car. However, while lease payments can be fully deductible, loan payments are not. Only the interest portion of a car loan payment is typically deductible. The monthly payments for leasing a car are usually lower than the monthly payments for a car loan for a similar vehicle. However, while lease payments can be subtracted from taxes, loan payments cannot. Only the interest part of a car loan payment is generally eligible for tax deduction. 

Feature Lease Loan
Taxable income Lease payments are not deductible, so your taxable income remains the same. Loan interest is deductible, so you can reduce your taxable income by the amount of interest you paid each year.
Property taxes You may be responsible for paying property taxes on your leased car, depending on your state's laws. You are responsible for paying property taxes on your financed car.
Sales taxes You will have to pay sales tax on the entire purchase price of your leased car, up front. You will only have to pay sales tax on the amount of money you finance for your car.
Depreciation You do not own the car you lease, so you cannot take advantage of depreciation. You own the car you finance, so you can take advantage of depreciation, which reduces the value of your car for tax purposes over time.
Total cost of ownership The total cost of ownership of a leased car is typically higher than the total cost of ownership of a financed car, because you do not own the car at the end of the lease term. The total cost of ownership of a financed car is typically lower than the total cost of ownership of a leased car, because you own the car at the end of the loan term.

Credit Score Considerations for Businesses: Lease or Buy a Car for Business

Financing and Creditworthiness

A business's credit score determines leasing terms or interest rates on car loans. A higher credit score can mean better financing terms, leading to lower monthly payments and potentially more favorable tax deductions. A company's credit score plays a crucial role in determining the terms of lease or interest rates on auto loans. A higher credit score could result in more favorable financing terms, leading to reduced monthly payments and potentially more advantageous tax deductions. 

The Impact of Ending a Lease Early on Business Finances

Financial and Tax Consequences

Ending a lease early can lead to penalties, including the obligation to pay the remaining lease payments. These costs can significantly affect a business's financial health and should be carefully considered before terminating a lease. Terminating a lease before it's due can result in fees, such as being responsible for the remaining lease payments. These expenses can significantly impact a company's financial well-being and should be thoughtfully weighed before ending the lease agreement. 

Insurance Differences for Leased vs Owned Business Vehicles

Required Coverage Levels

Leased vehicles typically require more comprehensive insurance coverage than owned vehicles, which can increase the overall cost of leasing. However, these costs may be partially offset by tax deductions for business use. Vehicles that are leased usually need more extensive insurance coverage than those that are owned, leading to higher leasing costs. Nevertheless, these expenses might be partially balanced by tax benefits for business-related usage. 

Weighing the Pros and Cons: Buy or Lease a New Car For Your Business

Financial and Tax Implications

Leasing offers lower initial costs and potential tax benefits from deductible lease payments, but it doesn't result in ownership. Buying a car can be more cost-effective over time and allows for asset accumulation, but it requires a larger initial investment. Renting provides lower upfront expenses and possible tax advantages through deductible rent payments. However, it does not lead to ownership. Purchasing a vehicle may be more economical in the long run and enables the accumulation of assets, but it demands a larger initial capital outlay. 

Making an Informed Business Decision: To Lease or Not to Lease?

Strategic Decision-Making

Leasing or buying a car should align with the business's overall strategy and financial goals. Factors like tax implications, cash flow needs, credit considerations, and long-term financial planning should be thoroughly evaluated to make the best choice for the business. The choice between leasing and purchasing a car should align with the company's overarching strategy and financial objectives. It is important to carefully assess factors such as tax consequences, cash flow requirements, credit assessments, and future financial planning to determine the most suitable option for the business. 

Key Takeaways: Navigating the Decision to Lease or Buy a Car for Business

  • Lease Payments vs. Buying Costs: Lease payments are typically lower than loan payments for buying a new car, making leasing a cost-effective option for businesses looking for lower monthly expenses.
  • End of Lease Term Considerations: At the end of a lease term, businesses must decide whether to return the car, extend the lease, or buy the leased vehicle. This flexibility is one of the pros of leasing a car.
  • Impact of Credit Score: A high credit score is beneficial whether you decide to lease or buy a car, as it affects the terms of a lease agreement or a car loan.
  • Leasing for New Vehicles: Leasing is a popular choice for businesses wanting to drive a new car every few years without the commitment of ownership.
  • Depreciation and Ownership: Buying a car allows businesses to build equity in the vehicle, but also involves depreciation, especially for new cars.
  • Pros and Cons of Leasing: Leasing offers lower upfront costs and is generally better for short-term use. However, it includes mileage restrictions and wear and tear policies.
  • Tax Implications: The lease or buy decision can significantly impact a business's tax situation. Lease payments on a business car are often tax-deductible, whereas buying a car allows for depreciation deductions.
  • Exiting a Lease Early: Ending a lease early can lead to substantial financial penalties, which is an important consideration when signing a lease contract.
  • Buying Used vs. New: Purchasing a used car can be a more economical than buying or leasing a new vehicle, especially in terms of depreciation.
  • Lease vs. Buy for Long-Term Use: Buying may be a better choice if you plan to keep a car for many years as it allows equity building. Leasing is better for regularly upgrading to a new vehicle.
  • Vehicle Usage: How much and in what manner you plan to use the car (e.g., for business purposes) can influence whether leasing or buying is more advantageous.
  • Insurance Costs: Car insurance requirements and costs vary between leased and owned vehicles. Leased cars usually require more comprehensive coverage.
  • Future Value Considerations: When you buy a car, the future value of the car is an important consideration, whereas with a lease, you don’t have to worry about the car’s value at the end of the lease.
  • Flexibility in Changing Vehicles: Leasing allows changing vehicles at the end of the lease term without the hassle of selling or trading in a car.
  • Business Usage and Mileage: For businesses using cars for extensive travel, leasing might impose mileage limitations, which could lead to additional charges.

These points underscore the importance of carefully considering financial and operational aspects when deciding to lease or buy a car, especially in a business context. The decision should align with the company's long-term financial strategy and immediate operational needs.

Conclusion

 When considering whether to buy or lease a car, weighing the pros and cons of each option is important. If you prefer to have the ability to customize and drive the car for an extended period of time, then buying the car may be the best option for you. However, car leasing could be a better fit if you prefer the flexibility of selling your car or switching to a new one after a few years. For example, a three-year lease allows you to enjoy a new car without the long-term commitment of car ownership. At the end of the lease, you can either keep the car by buying it or simply return it and lease another one. Ultimately, the decision to buy or lease a car depends on your personal preferences and lifestyle.

How can Taxfyle help?

Finding an accountant to file your taxes is a big decision. Luckily, you don't have to handle the search on your own. 

At Taxfyle, we connect individuals and small businesses with licensed, experienced CPAs or EAs in the US. We handle the hard part of finding the right tax professional by matching you with a Pro who has the right experience to meet your unique needs and will handle filing taxes for you.

Get started with Taxfyle today, and see how filing taxes can be simplified. 

Legal Disclaimer

Tickmark, Inc. and its affiliates do not provide legal, tax or accounting advice. The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal, tax or accounting advice or recommendations. All information prepared on this site is for informational purposes only, and should not be relied on for legal, tax or accounting advice. You should consult your own legal, tax or accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction. The content on this website is provided “as is;” no representations are made that the content is error-free.

Was this post helpful?
Yes, thanks!
Not really
Thank you for your feedback
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Did you know business owners can spend over 100 hours filing taxes?
Yes
No
Is this article answering your questions?
Yes
No
Are you filing your own taxes?
Yes
No
How is your work-life balance?
Good
Bad
Do you do your own bookkeeping?
Yes
No
Is your firm falling behind during the busy season?
Yes
No
Did you know business owners can spend over 100 hours filing taxes?
Yes
No
Is this article answering your questions?
Yes
No
Do you do your own bookkeeping?
Yes
No
Are you filing your own taxes?
Yes
No
How is your work-life balance?
Good
Bad
Is your firm falling behind during the busy season?
Yes
No
Did you know you can save your business money by paying less in taxes?
Yes
No
Is this article answering your questions?
Yes
No
Are you missing out on potential tax credits and deductions?
Yes
No
I don't know
How is your work-life balance?
Good
Bad
Do you do your own bookkeeping?
Yes
No
Is your firm falling behind during the busy season?
Yes
No
Did you know you can save your business money by paying less in taxes?
Yes
No
Are you missing out on potential tax credits and deductions?
Yes
No
I don't know
How is your work-life balance?
Good
Bad
Is your firm falling behind during the busy season?
Yes
No
Do you do your own bookkeeping?
Yes
No
Is this article answering your questions?
Yes
No

published

November 16, 2023

in

Antonio Del Cueto, CPA

Read

by this author

Share this article
>